Richard Bachman’s Thinner: Billy, Taduz, and the Cycle of Revenge (Also, Richie Ginelli!)

At first it seems like a simple horror story: A family man wrongs a Gypsy who subsequently curses him with a horrific fate. Understandably, the main selling point was the curse itself, obese Billy Halleck doomed to grow thinner and thinner until he wastes away completely. But the story is so much more, a complex and disturbing exploration of culpability and the vicious cycle  of revenge.

(My main source for discussion is the novel, but I will also utilize references and images from Tom Holland’s excellent film, a quite faithful adaptation)

At first we our naturally inclined to view Taduz as pure evil. After all, what cruel and disgusting fates to inflict on a man who only accidentally killed his daughter and the cop and judge who white-washed the inquest. However, the novel goes more into detail about the background of the Lemke clan and all the injustices they have faced over the year. Susanna’s death, denied justice by the legal system, is only the latest in a long line of offenses inflicted on the Gypsies by the town folk. Always a different town, always a different authority, but always the same bum deal. SSDD. The officer who conveniently neglectfulness to give Billy a breathalizer test, himself a victim of another one of Taduz’s curse, does the best summation, about how the Gypsies are always driven out of town, how they are treated like dirt by “proper” members of society, their children beaten and their women raped. And now, on top of a lifetime of persecution, Taduz’s daughter is killed and no one seems to give a damn.

But don’t get me wrong. Taduz is absolutely NOT justified in the evil he puts on Billy, the cop, and the judge. It’s such a painful and horrific curse. Sadistic. For the majority of the story, Billy is this victim and Taduz the perpetrator of the evil, regardless of how it began. So, who do I root for?

RICHIE “THE HAMMER” GINELLI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Perhaps my favorite Stephen King character.  Ginelli is a charismatic, pragmatic, worldly man, and in a horror story plagued by a Gypsy curse, he was able to uses his wits, resources and tenacity to emerge as the unlikely anti-hero. Ginelli is not a ghostbuster, priest or paranormal investigator; he’s a seemingly run of the mill hood. And yet he drops his skepticism as soon as he sees his friend Billy’s situation, and commits himself, quite capably presents a very real threat to the evil magician. I just like the idea of a secular man rising to this supernatural occasion without hesitation and with his tenacious gusto, and his attitude “The definition of an a-hole is a guy who doesn’t believe what he’s seeing.” And there is a certain satisfaction in seeing Ginelli pose a serious threat to Taduz, a magician whose cruelty inspires such hatred.

Some badass quotes from the book:

Ginelli: I don’t have much time, asshole, so listen good. You tell the old man that next time I won’t be shooting high or low or at empty cars. Tell him William Halleck says to take it off. You got that?
Samuel Lemke: You don’t understand. He’ll never take it off. He’s the last of the great Magyar chiefs-his heart is a brick. Please, mister, I’ll remember, but he’ll nevertake it off.
Ginelli: Bricks can be crushed. Tell him that too.

Later, confronting Gina, Taduz’s fierce and beautiful great-granddaughter:

A photo of Kari Wuhrer wasnt necessary for this post, but whos complaining?

A photo of Kari Wuhrer wasn't absolutely necessary for this post, but who's complaining?

Ginelli: What do you think this is, a game? You throw a curse onto someone with a wife and a kid, you think it is a game? You think he hit that woman, your gramma, on purpose? You think he had a contract on her? You think the Mafia had a contract put out on your old grandmother?”

Ginelli is saying exactly what we’re all thinking and it is oh so satisfying to see him kick ace and take names. Ginelli is, of course, a vicious thug, an unrepentant criminal and murderer. So why do I like him? It it his loyalty to his friend, his downright fearlessness and tenacity? Or is it just because he stands as as the only capable opponent to such a loathsomely wicked man?

Taduz Lemke is like John Doe from Se7en or Jigsaw. While they may have have had legitimate grievences (Lemke especially), any point they were trying to make is overshadowed by the shear savagry and disgusting nature of their disproportionate punishment. Taduz had every right to be outraged at the injustices towards his daughter, his family, his whole people, but he had no right to put such a slow and painful and deliberately cruel death on anyone. So you’ve got “The Sight”, do you old man? And we all know you have the power! So why don’t you use it for good? Why don’t you help your own family out of their troubles, instead of malicious curses. Why does your ‘justice’  have to take such an ugly, slow form? Who is this mobster bursting in, killing your dogs and threatening to throw acid in the face of your children, and hey, why am I cheering him on?

By the end, Taduz seems to come to his senses. He realizes that Ginelli is even more ruthless than he is, that The Hammer will never cease to fall until he’s nailed in his own victory. Taduz knows that Ginelli absolutely will hurt women and children, the very family he was trying to do justice to in the first place. So he takes the curse off, but he cannot take the consequences back. All in all, there have already four dead people killed at this point, and how many lives ruined and yet to be? So, old man, was it worth it? You never pretended it would bring your daughter back, but is your family better for all this evil you’ve continued? Is anything?

This story is a cycle of everyone doing wrong, and no one owning up to it. You shouldn’t distract your husband when he’s driving. You shouldn’t let your wife distract you. You shouldn’t walk out into the street without looking both ways. You shouldn’t white wash the case and let a man get off scot-free on vehicular manslaughter. You shouldn’t curse peope, either with your Gypsy magic or your mobster buddy. You shouldn’t wish your wife dead and make her eat the curse either. Evil only begets evil, and two wrongs make a right, and no one in this whole sordid story is willing to accept that and take responsibility for their own sins. Everything is always somebody else’s fault, somebody else’s responsibility, and somebody else must pay. It’s push, push, POOSH, and by the end, it’s Billy’s 14 year old daughter Linda, the only true innocent in the whole damn book, who ends up paying.

About that.

When I first read it, I thought that Billy, horrified at the fate he’s passed onto his daughter, decided to finally take on responsibility himself and eat the curse. But now I wonder if the Purpufargade Ansiket had actually been taken care of by Linda and Heidi (I mean, how many people can one curse- likened by Lemke to a baby- possess), and Billy was just eating a regular pie, wallowing in his self-inflicted misery.

My textual basis? Although the pie was still pulsating after Heidi and Linda had got to it, it stops when Billy goes to take his piece:

“Why not?’ he whispered, and pulled the wrapping off the pie. Now it was still again. Now it was just a strawberry pie that looked extremely tempting in spite of the earliness of the hour.

And as Heidi herself had said, he still needed all the calories he could get.

‘Eat hearty,’ Billy Halleck whispered in the sunny silence of the kitchen, and cut himself a piece of Gypsy pie.”

The pie has stopped pulsating with the sickening life of the Purpufargade Ansiket and it looks like something delicious to eat. Recall that had no appetite or hunger for the duration of the curse. And what if the mention of calories gained by eating a pie is not ironic.

I think that Billy surviving his family, uncursed, actually makes for a stronger ending that is both more thematically fitting and perhaps even more disturbing then magically rotting to death. Billy’s arc through the novel is a descent from irresponsibility and denial into outright evil. First he tells himself that hitting Susana wasn’t his fault, trying to blame Heidi for distracting him. Then when Lemke refuses to accept his notion of collective responsibility (“No poosh!”), Billy puts The Curse of The White Man From Town on Lemke, siccing his vicious, merciless and all-around badass mobster friend Richie Ginelli on the whole Gypsy clan. Although at this point Billy still impotently tells Richie not to hurt anybody. Billy grows more bitter and hateful towards his wife and Dr. Hopley, so by the end is sadistically pleased to pass the curse on to Heidi. Throughout the book Billy is trying to push responsibility onto others, with less and less regard for the innocent. In their last meeting Lemke tells Billy “Everyone pays, even for thinks they dint do.”

So, is the discovery that Linda also ate of the pie the catalyst that finally pushes a man already this low to finally take responsibility for his crimes? OR is this the final revelation of just how evil Billy has become? Recall that in the beginning of the book, it is mentioned that Billy never lost sleep or his appetite over the questionably scrupulous practices of his law firm. So with that in mind, could Billy seeing the pie as tempting food be genuine, concerned with his own appetites and desires, even with the full knowledge of the monstrous fate he has given to his daughter, his descent to the dark side complete? I think this believable moral degradation (we’re with Billy every step of the way) of an ordinary man into a complete monster is far more frightening than the simple visceral horror of people rotted to death. Seeing a body waste a way is disgusting. Seeing a soul turn black chills you to the bone.

I think that Richard Bachman intended the ending to be Billy dying with his family, finally taking his piece of the pie. But what if Billy actually survives, healthy and happy in his wickedness? I prefer my interpretation, and I think it gives you a lot of contemplation to chew on.

Eat hearty, my friends.

169 Responses to “Richard Bachman’s Thinner: Billy, Taduz, and the Cycle of Revenge (Also, Richie Ginelli!)”

  1. scam site hosting Says:

    …Awesome website…

    [...]The whole look of your web site is fantastic, let well as the content material![...]…

  2. advance cash Online Says:

    advance cash Online…

  3. fast payday loan payday Loan Says:

    fast payday loan payday Loan…

  4. instant cash payday loans Says:

    instant cash payday loans…

  5. fast cash till payday Says:

    fast cash till payday…

  6. best deal on loans Says:

    best deal on loans…

  7. best price loans Says:

    best price loans…

  8. best unsecured loans for bad credit Says:

    best unsecured loans for bad credit…

  9. best personal loan rates Says:

    best personal loan rates…

  10. website Says:

    website…

  11. best loans Says:

    best loans…

  12. best loans for bad credit Says:

    best loans for bad credit…

  13. Loan Broker Says:

    Loan Broker…

  14. Great Loans site Says:

    Great Loans site…

  15. Best Buy Loans Says:

    Best Buy Loans…

  16. best loan deals Says:

    best loan deals…

  17. best loans available Says:

    best loans available…

  18. Best loan offers Says:

    Best loan offers…

  19. best uk loans Says:

    best uk loans…

  20. just click the following web page Says:

    just click the following web page…

  21. Go to sololalazio.blog.tiscali.it Says:

    Go to sololalazio.blog.tiscali.it…

  22. the best loan deals Says:

    the best loan deals…

  23. best tenant loans Says:

    best tenant loans…

  24. Personal loans Says:

    Personal loans…

  25. best loans uk Says:

    best loans uk…

  26. just click the following article Says:

    just click the following article…

  27. This Internet page Says:

    This Internet page…

  28. Best secured loans Says:

    Best secured loans…

  29. best loan deal Says:

    best loan deal…

  30. best unsecured loans Says:

    best unsecured loans…

  31. resources Says:

    resources…

  32. Recommended reading Says:

    Recommended reading…

  33. The Best Loans Says:

    The Best Loans…

  34. best loans on the market Says:

    best loans on the market…

  35. best bank loan Says:

    best bank loan…

  36. linked web-site Says:

    linked web-site…

  37. read on Says:

    read on…

  38. best rates for loans Says:

    best rates for loans…

  39. best loan Says:

    best loan…

  40. homepage Says:

    homepage…

  41. best loans rates Says:

    best loans rates…

  42. linked resource site Says:

    linked resource site…

  43. unsecured loans Says:

    unsecured loans…

  44. best personal loans Says:

    best personal loans…

  45. view the site Says:

    view the site…

  46. best small loans Says:

    best small loans…

  47. Compare Best Loans Says:

    Compare Best Loans…

  48. Best personal Loan Says:

    Best personal Loan…

  49. Best Payday Loans Uk Says:

    Best Payday Loans Uk…

  50. best loan deals uk Says:

    best loan deals uk…

  51. home-page Says:

    home-page…

  52. best bank loan rates Says:

    best bank loan rates…

  53. relevant webpage Says:

    relevant webpage…

  54. best homeowner loans Says:

    best homeowner loans…

  55. related site Says:

    related site…

  56. Highly recommended reading Says:

    Highly recommended reading…

  57. just click the following page Says:

    just click the following page…

  58. best apr loans Says:

    best apr loans…

  59. view the following website Says:

    view the following website…

  60. Extra resources Says:

    Extra resources…

  61. view this weblink Says:

    view this weblink…

  62. blog.Itu.dk Says:

    blog.Itu.dk…

  63. Highly recommended resource Says:

    Highly recommended resource…

  64. relevant internet page Says:

    relevant internet page…

  65. best loan companies Says:

    best loan companies…

  66. best rate loan Says:

    best rate loan…

  67. best deals on loans Says:

    best deals on loans…

  68. best bank loans Says:

    best bank loans…

  69. best unsecured loan Says:

    best unsecured loan…

  70. best loans deals Says:

    best loans deals…

  71. please click the following internet site Says:

    please click the following internet site…

  72. best value loans Says:

    best value loans…

  73. view the next web site Says:

    view the next web site…

  74. best payday loans Says:

    best payday loans…

  75. Full posting Says:

    Full posting…

  76. relevant website Says:

    relevant website…

  77. linked webpage Says:

    linked webpage…

  78. www.halomd.net Says:

    http://www.halomd.net...

  79. please click the following post Says:

    please click the following post…

  80. Follow this link Says:

    Follow this link…

  81. see the web-site Says:

    see the web-site…

  82. This Site Says:

    This Site…

  83. Suggested Web page Says:

    Suggested Web page…

  84. please click www.olympicbusinesspages.com Says:

    please click http://www.olympicbusinesspages.com...

  85. link Says:

    link…

  86. more Says:

    more…

  87. pavlo.kr Says:

    pavlo.kr…

  88. article continued Says:

    article continued…

  89. relevant web site Says:

    relevant web site…

  90. click for more Says:

    click for more…

  91. keep reading Says:

    keep reading…

  92. best rate loans Says:

    best rate loans…

  93. related web site Says:

    related web site…

  94. www.yonis.ch Says:

    http://www.yonis.ch...

  95. Check it out Says:

    Check it out…

  96. facetunisia.hostingsiteforfree.com Says:

    facetunisia.hostingsiteforfree.com…

  97. view this link Says:

    view this link…

  98. More information and facts Says:

    More information and facts…

  99. see the webpage Says:

    see the webpage…

  100. Read the complete guide Says:

    Read the complete guide…

  101. Highly recommended web-site Says:

    Highly recommended web-site…

  102. Full document Says:

    Full document…

  103. Read More at this website Says:

    Read More at this website…

  104. More suggestions Says:

    More suggestions…

  105. view this web page link Says:

    view this web page link…

  106. view this website Says:

    view this website…

  107. Small Loans Fast Cash Says:

    Small Loans Fast Cash…

  108. Check out www.quipunet.org Says:

    Check out http://www.quipunet.org...

  109. Suggested Webpage Says:

    Suggested Webpage…

  110. Go here Says:

    Go here…

  111. Read Even more Says:

    Read Even more…

  112. senaz.blogsome.com Says:

    senaz.blogsome.com…

  113. linked internet site Says:

    linked internet site…

  114. Read the full report Says:

    Read the full report…

  115. com.sg Says:

    com.sg…

  116. Go to this site Says:

    Go to this site…

  117. just click the following web site Says:

    just click the following web site…

  118. view the next website page Says:

    view the next website page…

  119. this website Says:

    this website…

  120. www.thespmm.com Says:

    http://www.thespmm.com...

  121. view the post Says:

    view the post…

  122. linked web page Says:

    linked web page…

  123. view the document Says:

    view the document…

  124. see the site Says:

    see the site…

  125. view the following web site Says:

    view the following web site…

  126. view the following page Says:

    view the following page…

  127. view the next web page Says:

    view the next web page…

  128. blogs.law.Batir.tv Says:

    blogs.law.Batir.tv…

  129. lazarhosting.com Says:

    lazarhosting.com…

  130. fast cash loans online Says:

    fast cash loans online…

  131. please click for source Says:

    please click for source…

  132. related webpage Says:

    related webpage…

  133. Full guide Says:

    Full guide…

  134. related resource site Says:

    related resource site…

  135. relevant site Says:

    relevant site…

  136. gocamping.org Says:

    gocamping.org…

  137. Home page Says:

    Home page…

  138. related website Says:

    related website…

  139. Continuing article Says:

    Continuing article…

  140. please click wiki.paraguayeduca.org Says:

    please click wiki.paraguayeduca.org…

  141. This Resource site Says:

    This Resource site…

  142. Highly recommended site Says:

    Highly recommended site…

  143. linked web site Says:

    linked web site…

  144. view the article Says:

    view the article…

  145. view the next page Says:

    view the next page…

  146. Read the full content Says:

    Read the full content…

  147. see the internet site Says:

    see the internet site…

  148. fromthehornetsnest.Blogspot.fr Says:

    fromthehornetsnest.Blogspot.fr…

  149. Read More In this article Says:

    Read More In this article…

  150. fast online cash Says:

    fast online cash…

  151. relevant resource site Says:

    relevant resource site…

  152. view the following internet site Says:

    view the following internet site…

  153. view the following web page Says:

    view the following web page…

  154. Full report Says:

    Full report…

  155. view the website Says:

    view the website…

  156. linked site Says:

    linked site…

  157. Recommended browsing Says:

    Recommended browsing…

  158. More about the author Says:

    More about the author…

  159. please click the following internet page Says:

    please click the following internet page…

  160. Suggested Studying Says:

    Suggested Studying…

  161. Our site Says:

    Our site…

  162. view website Says:

    view website…

  163. see the web site Says:

    see the web site…

  164. raf662.com Says:

    raf662.com…

  165. fast cash loans with bad credit Says:

    fast cash loans with bad credit…

  166. Recommended web page Says:

    Recommended web page…

  167. please click the following website Says:

    please click the following website…

  168. Full write-up Says:

    Full write-up…

  169. view this hyperlink Says:

    view this hyperlink…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.